Comments

Comments that this user has made.

Commented on: Cake Contest – Cloudberry Cake – 4/5 Dungeon (1 Star) creation

I did not know that cloudberry cakes are a thing :D The design is looking really good, well done!

Approved.

If you would like to post one more cake design - please use the 5/5 counter in the name :)

Commented on: Cake Contest – Blueberry Cake – 3/5 Dungeon (1 Star) creation

Beautiful!

Happy to approve.

If you would like to post another cake design - please use the 4/5 counter in the name :)

Commented on: Cake Contest – Blueberry Cake – 3/5 Dungeon (1 Star) creation

Hello o/

Oh my, the blueberry sponges are looking SO delicious :O I love how gentle the whole cake design is!

However, when approaching from the sides players will be faced with a wall of white (there is a soft shading, but with the way trove light works it will not always be visible) :(  I completely understand that this is a whipped cream cover, but the cake needs to read like a cake from all sides more than it needs to be recipe-accurate.

I would suggest exposing the blueberry goodness all the way around - that way the players would see the most beautiful part of the cake from all sides and there would be absolutely no doubt that this is in fact a cake :) Such an approach seems to exist in real-life recipes too!

 

Im really hoping to see this cake back on Review!

Commented on: Cake Contest – Banana Cake – 2/5 Dungeon (1 Star) creation

Hello!

What a delicious looking banana cake! Loving the textures.

Approved!

 

If you would like to post another cake design - please use the 3/5 counter in the name :)

Commented on: Contemporaneous Carcharodontosaurus Helmet creation

@GooberBalls

Usually an approved creation stays approved because both the creator and moderators have spent time on getting it to an Approved stage, and most importantly the Developers might have already been evaluating the Approved creation to add it, so i would rather not interrupt the process.

However, it was my fault that i approved it right away without giving you a chance to process feedback, so i think it could be reasonable to allow edits. That would mean that the creation goes back to Active and would need to go through Review again before it could reach Approved. Would you prefer this option? If the changes you want to make are very drastic, it might be better to upload a new helmet creation instead.

 

Also, there is a Creation Contest running during the whole March - create a Cake dungeon room for the upcoming Sunfest event - check it out, may be you would like to participate :) https://trovesaurus.com/page=5256 

Commented on: Cake Contest – Sundered Cake – 1/5 Dungeon (1 Star) creation

Hello there!

The cake is looking good, i really like it that the chocolate biscuits go all the way to the top :D

Im assuming its meant to be a fondant kind of cake? Its a bit to hard to tell from the back that it is edible, but i think this design will read alright as a cake since you kept the overall shape, good job!

Im going to approve this one, but if you would feel inspired to make more cakes - it might be good if you try to imagine how a design would taste like, and add visual elements that would highlight that. 

Approved.

If you would like to post another cake design - please use the 2/5 counter in the name :)

Commented on: Cake Contest – Dragon Lava Cake – 2/5 Dungeon (1 Star) creation

New version reads so much better! Good job :)

Approved.

If you would like to post another cake design - please use the 3/5 counter in the name :)