Skadi Edge

[Melee] [Permafrost]

Approved
2 weeks ago

by Marzes Home Files Download ZIP

Comments and Likes Comments 20

You must be logged in to add a comment.

Wow this sword looks very nice! :D

Creation Status Changed to Approved
by Ylva June 23, 2020

Hello again!

The base part is looking better :)

Cant say im fully satisfied with the overall impression, but if you think the sword reached its best possible appearance there isnt much i can keep pushing for :)

Approving it.

Creation Status Changed to Needs Review
by Marzes June 22, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Ylva June 20, 2020

Hello again!

Sword looks better, the 'eye' base has interesting shape and catchy appearance! Very well done on coloring and material maps on the blade, super nice chilly-ice effect :D

With the amount of swords you ve had on review im sure you know how picky i am with them :P Not because of personal preference, but because of the amount of melee styles in game.

Thus. While the base has attractive shape, its lacking a bit in shading. Current coloring makes it feel as if there are only 3 colors used, and that doesnt work too good together with the absolutely stunning coloring of the blade.

About the blade shape though, from the first glance it can be easily mistaken with Digital Daemon Dreadsabre blade, could be good to ensure your design has unique appearance.

Overall, it would be best to balance out the great shape of the base and great coloring of the blade to make it one complete good looking sword :) It is a really nice design already, hoping to see it finished.

Creation Status Changed to Needs Review
by Marzes June 18, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Marzes June 18, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Draft
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Needs Review
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Draft
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Needs Review
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Marzes May 14, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Draft
by Marzes April 25, 2020
Creation Status Changed to Active
by Ylva April 25, 2020

Hello!

Sword looks interesting, i like the color choices and idea!

However, there are over 900 various sword designs already in game so all newly approved swords have to be unique and extraordinary. While your sword is good, i think it could be spiced up a bit more to give it more chance to attract attention.

Im mostly concerned about all those repetitive elements on the blade part, its usually best to avoid busy shapes. Also since you are aiming for Permafrost, may be some icicles on the blade could enforce the impression? Another thing, rounded eye feels as rather commonly seen shape, may be it could be at least squared up a bit to make it look more unique?

Based on your model i tried couple of things just to see how it could look, its very far from being perfect though. Not in any case you need to copy it, just hoping it could help you pick a direction for improvements :)

Going to set status of this one to Active for now, set it back to Needs Review if you upload any changes to the model :) If you d rather work on something completely different you could set status to Draft, that will free up a creation slot for another style and hide this one from the public list of Active.

In any case, good luck!

Creation Status Changed to Needs Review
by Marzes April 25, 2020
Info

Progress

Added

Rewarded

Accepted

Approved

Needs Review

Active

Draft


Status

Created 3 months ago

Updated 2 weeks ago

Approved 2 weeks ago

This Creation was Approved by Creation Moderators and is waiting to be considered by Trove Developers for Acceptance.

Activity

Skadi Edge status has been set to Approved

Ylva 2 weeks ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Needs Review

Marzes 2 weeks ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Active

Ylva 3 weeks ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Needs Review

Marzes 3 weeks ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Active

Marzes 3 weeks ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Draft

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Active

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Needs Review

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Active

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Draft

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Active

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Needs Review

Marzes 2 months ago

Skadi Edge status has been set to Active

Marzes 2 months ago

Key of Skadi status has been set to Draft

Marzes 2 months ago

Key of Skadi status has been set to Active

Ylva 2 months ago

Key of Skadi status has been set to Needs Review

Marzes 2 months ago