View Comment

Commented on Laval Scimitar Melee creation

Hello again!

I see sword getting further and further from the original design with every fix :P I really liked the line of fire on the very edge, was looking very clean and elegant, but i suppose there is a charm to current design aswell.

About the pommel once again. You reduced the side but it still does not fit in the box... i know there are lots of sword designs that have huge pommels but we have these restrictions now exactly because of them.

May be it would be alright with you if pommel didnt have glass at all? Removing that and coloring it into same fiery colors as on the edge (instead of plain red) doesnt look all too bad. Design i tried (sword on the bottom of image) still goes outside of the dimension box (black stick with AP in the middle) but i suppose if there is absolutely no other way to make your idea work i could approve something like that. It would be risky and could prevent Devs from Accepting it though so i highly recommend you try some design that completely fits in.

As a thought, the sword seems to be losing quite a lot of uniqueness as we try to fit it in the boundaries. May be you could catch some wild inspiration to add some spark to the design?

I honestly wish i could approve every good sword without trying to push its limits but it is the most 'done' category of styles and there is a huge chance that Dev team would prefer to accept an 'ok' Fist over 'quite good' Sword.

Going to set status to Active for now, hoping you can make this one work.