View Comment

Commented on Banana's Justice Staff creation

Hello!

What a fun idea! I like how silly and Trovian it feels :D

Unfortunately there are some things that need to be fixed before i could approve this.

Creations can not contain floating or corner-connected elements. Yes there are some designs like that in game, but they are exactly why we have this rule now. That banana would need to be connected to the shaft.

The size of you staff fits in the dimensions indeed, but they are given 'around' the Attachment point, if one side has less space used it doesnt mean the other side can use more space. Moving your AP to the back end of the staff by 2-3 voxels should solve that :)

Im glad you tried material maps, they really do bring shine and glow :) However there seem to be some confusion about them. On the left is your design, top to bottom Main model, type map, alpha map and specular map. On the right is mapping that could work, not talking design here but only technical side for now.

For the note, i do think transparent banana would look a bit too much like a crescent moon so i wouldnt use alpha on it. But i might be wrong and it could turn out just great :P

Going to set status of your creation to Active for now, set it back to Review if you update the post. If you would rather work on creating something completely else you could set it to Draft, that would free up a slot for new creation.